Healthcare Reform Talk
August 28th, 2009I saw the following video on Liberally Lean tonight. I think it makes a lot of valid points. I don’t fall easily to either side of the discussion on healthcare. It has both pros and cons, yet people always seem to be so sure any plan for reform is either awesome or totally evil. Wow, if it were so easy. I can say that I saw no errors or erroneous claims in the video. I have seen the statistics that validate the claim that Medicare and Medicaid only spend around three percent on administrative costs. (Which also makes me wonder why other government entities can’t figure out how to cut administrative costs in other agencies and programs???) I have also seen stats that show some private insurers can spend as much as 35% of our premiums on administration.
I have made a point thus far to stay out of discussions about healthcare reform. I see the masses of people arguing their side, spouting off hot sports opinions on healthcare, waving signs, and being absolutely sure of their position. The thought of having to discuss this topic with someone gives me an extreme case of tired head. What really makes my head want to explode is that 98.925% of these people have absolutely no idea what the heck they are talking about. They choose a side, usually based on party affiliation, feelings toward government involvement, etc, without a clue as to what Obama’s (or anyone else’s) proposal even contains. For those that may actually take the time to read it, how many have even the SLIGHTEST clue of the intricacies and complexities of the issue. My estimation 1:5,000,000 can eloquently state the facts for and against and give solid reasons for their opinion. I doubt I could have a healthcare discussion with someone even if it was quiet and civilized, which I have yet to see. Yelling in a Senator’s face? Yeah, I’m sure that guy had a perfect solution to healthcare reform.
I believe I have a much better understanding of the healthcare debate than the average American due to my degrees, research, and professional experiences (if you want to know what these are, leave a comment with your email). I can argue for and against it. I can give you statistics, proposals for solutions, and reasons none of those will work. In order for broad-sweeping healthcare reform to truly take place, one thing must happen: complete and utter collapse. Think post-Great Depression reform to regulate and control the financial industry. This DOES NOT make me an expert, but I think it gives me a somewhat reasonable understanding of the issue.
Access to care, preventative medicine, lobbyists, incongruent insurance filing standards, administrative costs, marketing costs, lack of transparency in pricing, pay-for-performance compensation structures, improper use of specialists for common ailments, underused equipment, overused staff, direct-to-consumer marketing, prescription drug costs, foreign drug costs, poor reporting requirements, policy enforcement issues, standards of care, and a whole mess of other topics all must be researched and evaluated as they relate to policy change. So, what’s the quick, easy fix I ask?
There is a benefit to universal healthcare and there are many things it must include and many things it must not include. There is a definite downside to that same coverage. But guess what? There are significant pros and cons to our current system, or ANY system for that matter.
I would love to hear your thoughts on universal coverage and healthcare reform so leave me a comment. I am willing to discuss if you like, but I also reserve the right to block any comments not clean, appropriate, or well thought out. And if I get fired up again without feeling beaten down, I may write a post with more specifics in the near future, or respond to questions and comments if there are any.


